The Binary Scenario for Chemical Peculiarities in Stars: History, Successes and Challenges

Alain Jorissen

Abstract

The chemical peculiarities observed in several classes of stars (like barium and CH stars) are now customarily attributed to the 'binary scenario', first expressed by McClure (1980), which states that the atmosphere of the present giant star has been polluted by matter enriched in carbon and heavy elements transferred from a companion formerly on the AGB (now a dim white dwarf - WD). Despite being initially doubtful, D. Lambert finally adhered to this scenario with two cornerstone papers (Smith & Lambert, 1988, ApJ 333, 219; Smith, Coleman & Lambert, 1993 ApJ 417, 287).

More than 20 years have elapsed since the advent of the 'binary scenario', and many successes have been obtained in its framework: (i) the finding of Ba and C dwarfs, as well as of WIRRing and Abell-35-like systems (relatively wide binaries whose primary has been spun up by mass transfer - possibly wind accretion); (ii) the similarity between orbital elements of (Tc-poor) S stars and barium stars, indicating that these two classes only differ in their effective temperatures, but that their members have followed the same binary evolution; (iii) the finding that yellow symbiotic stars are metal-deficient barium stars.

Nevertheless, several challenges remain: (i) No mass transfer scenario can so far satisfactorily reproduce the observed eccentricity-period diagram, unless dramatic orbital shrinkage during case C of Roche Lab Overflow may be avoided; (i) Why are there no S stars among red symbiotics, and why not all metal-deficient barium stars are symbiotics?

In order to answer the latter question, fast methods to assess the binary nature of stars may be of interest. Some non-conventional, recently-developed methods will be briefly presented:

(i) How to use astrometric data in a most efficient way to probe the possible binary nature of a target star? This method, which has been developed on the Hipparcos Intermediate Astrometric Data, will gain a renewed interest when SIM and GAIA data will become available; (ii) A discrepancy between the Tycho-2 and HIP proper motions hints at the star being a binary with a period longer than about 5 years.



















17-19 June 2004
Cosmic Abundances as Records of Stellar Evolution and Nucleosynthesis
In Honor of Professor David Lambert
Austin, Texas